logo-footer

National Science and Technology Forum (NSTF)

Criteria of Assessment

The criteria for evaluation of nominees are clearly laid out in the relevant nomination forms.

Forms should be completed between Stage 1 (registration) and Stage 2 (submission of completed nomination forms) of the process. Examples of the nomination forms can be viewed and downloaded here below, in order for nominators to see what information is required. These are examples only and should not be filled in. The relevant nomination form will be made available on e-mail to the nominator and nominee in Microsoft Word format, once Stage 1 (registration) has been completed. For information purposes, the following criteria broadly apply:

All categories

The following criteria broadly apply to assessing all categories of the awards:

Section 1

Background and contribution to the advancement of science/technological innovation/new knowledge generated:

  • The inputs to this contribution
  • The research process (where applicable)
  • The development process (where applicable)

Section 2

Outputs –What has been done with this contribution:

  • The outputs (as a summary which does not need to include the detail given under subsequent bullets)
  • The practical application / implementation / impact and commercial or economic impact where there has been such.
  • Relevance to South Africa (SA) and its people and resultant contribution to science, engineering and technology (SET) and innovation policy
  • Publications and patents (in some categories, e.g. Innovation category, this information is regarded as incidental)
  • Promotion of public understanding of SET or science engagement

Section 3

Students, education and development of human capital, sustainability and recognition

  • Supervision of students where applicable; and promotion of education in this field as a contribution to the public understanding of SET (this is more for incidental information in the Innovation categories and the Communication category and less critical to their assessment)
  • Social and economic sustainability
  • National and international impact and recognition

Samples of nomination forms

The interpretation of criteria in relation to each of the awards is clarified in the samples of nomination forms below.

  1. Awards for individuals for contributions to SET and innovation:
  • NSTF-CSIR Lifetime Achievement Award
  • TW Kambule-NSTF Researcher Award for research and its outputs
  • TW Kambule-NSTF Emerging Researcher Award for research and its outputs
  • Management Award for management of SET and innovation and related activities
  1. Engineering Research Capacity Development Award
  2. NSTF-Water Research Commission (WRC) Award for sustainable water management, knowledge generation and solutions
  3. NSTF-SAMRC Clinician Scientist Award
  4. NSTF-TIA Green Economy Award for biodiversity conservation, environmental sustainability and a greener economy
  5. Science Diplomacy for Africa Award for impactful solutions and/or collaborations for the benefit of SA and the African continent
  6. NSTF-Agricultural Research Council (ARC) Award for agricultural research and solutions

8. Research Software Awards

  • All scientific fields including natural science, and humanities and social sciences (HSS)
  • NSTF-SADiLaR Research Software: Human Language Technologies (HLT)

9. Data for Research Award for advancing the availability, management and re-use of research data

10. Innovation Awards including their research and/or development

  • through a corporate organisation, or
  • Small, medium or micro enterprise (SMME)

11. Communication Award for outreach and creating awareness of SET and innovation

12. Non-Governmental Organisation (NGO) Award for SET and innovation related activities, including technology transfer, and education and training activities

13. Special Annual Theme Award: Ecosystem Restoration – awarded according to a nomination in any of the other categories. This category does not have a standalone nomination form. 

Additional Criteria

Certain additional criteria apply to specific categories. These can be viewed on the relevant category pages at the following links:

Individual Awards – Lifetime, Researcher, Emerging Researcher and Management

Engineering Research Capacity Development Award

Water Award

Clinician-Scientist Award

Green Economy Award

Science Diplomacy for Africa Award

Agricultural Award

Research Software Award

Data for Research Award

Innovation Awards – Corporate and SMME

Communication Award

NGO Award

Special Annual Theme Award: Ecosystem Restoration

NSTF-South32 Awards

SPONSORS AND PARTNERS

The NSTF supports the principle of collaborative, widely-inclusive awards and welcomes collaboration with members and other organisations interested, such as the following:

Subscribe to our eNews

Sign up to receive news on what is happening in science, engineering, technology (SET) and innovation in South Africa

Copyright © 2023 All Rights Reserved | National Science and Technology Forum (NSTF)